America magazine and other media outlets criticize NFL kicker Harrison Butker for his conservative Catholic-themed commencement address at Benedictine College, citing concerns about gender roles, Covid-19 policies, liturgical preferences, and abortion being included in the same speech. The speech was seen as promoting backward-looking sectarianism by some critics.
Key Points
Criticism from America magazine, Religion News Service, and others
Comparison made between liberal Catholics and Catholic haters
Butker's speech received poorly outside the Benedictine College community
Cons
Critics argue that Butker's speech promoted backward-looking sectarianism
Concerns raised about gender roles, Covid-19 policies, liturgical preferences, and abortion being addressed in the same speech