Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's remarks about Ukraine's pre-war borders with Russia spark controversy and criticism from Obama officials and Trump critics. Hegseth believes returning to Ukraine's pre-2014 borders is unrealistic and calls for Europe to offer security guarantees after the war, not the U.S.
Key Points
Hegseth believes a durable peace for Ukraine must ensure that the war will not reignite.
The U.S. does not see NATO membership for Ukraine as a realistic outcome of negotiations.
Hegseth calls for European troops to back security guarantees for Ukraine.
Critics question why concessions are made to Russia before negotiations begin and view it as giving Putin wins for free.
Cons
Critics argue that Hegseth's vocalization of beliefs on Ukraine's borders may weaken leverage in peace negotiations with Russia.
Some view the comments as a capitulation to Putin and a blow to U.S. national security interests.